When Passion Turns to Conflict: What Happens When Ownership of a Classic Car Is Disputed After Death?

At Arlingsworth, we often handle cases where family ties and valuable assets collide. One such matter involved a cherished classic car, originally purchased as a long-term investment, which became the centre of a heated inheritance dispute following the owner’s death.

The Story Behind the Dispute

Our client’s late husband purchased a limited-edition classic vehicle in 2002. It was intended as an investment and loaned to their son in 2005 under a witnessed agreement. The terms were clear: it was to be stored and occasionally exhibited but not sold or re-registered. Years later, after the husband passed away, his daughter-in-law changed the car’s registration into her name and began using it as her own. This was despite the original agreement and without the consent of our client or the estate.

Why Classic Cars Require More Than Just Sentimental Value

Classic vehicles often carry significant monetary worth, and disputes can become even more complicated when paperwork is ignored or misunderstood. In this case, despite the existence of a signed loan agreement, there had been no restriction preventing the transfer of the vehicle’s V5C (registration document) to another party.

Unfortunately, changing the registered keeper of a vehicle does not necessarily equate to a legal transfer of ownership, but it can be used as a defence in the absence of legal intervention.

Legal Options in Similar Situations

If you are facing a dispute involving a loaned or inherited vehicle, there are two main legal routes you can take:

  • Civil claim for ownership: You can file a claim for the return of the vehicle, especially if you have a loan agreement or proof that the car was not intended to change hands.

  • Criminal complaint: If the car was registered or used without authorisation, there may be grounds for a fraud investigation, particularly if forged signatures or dishonesty are involved.

The case we managed involved both aspects. The police were unwilling to act without a clear court order, so we supported our client in pursuing civil action, including injunctions to prevent further use of the vehicle and a claim for restitution.

Lessons for Future Classic Car Owners

If you own or invest in classic cars, especially as part of an estate plan, it is critical to:

  • Document ownership and loan terms clearly, including mileage limits or restrictions

  • Consider registering assets in a trust or company name for added legal protection

  • Include specific instructions in your will about vehicles and who is entitled to them

At Arlingsworth, we understand the nuances of family disputes and the emotional weight such cases carry. Whether the conflict is over a rare vehicle, heirloom, or property, our experienced solicitors offer strategic support tailored to your needs.

For confidential legal advice, contact us at:

📞 01273 696962
📩 info@arlingsworth.com